Skip to content

Toilet Zone

Really crappy news

How to Check Whether an Online Store Is Trustworthy Before You Buy

An online store displays a padlock in the address bar, features a polished design and offers attractive prices. These things aren’t enough to…

Femme vérifiant la fiabilité d'un site e-commerce sur son ordinateur portable dans un bureau à domicile

An online store may display a padlock in the address bar, feature a polished design and offer attractive prices. These factors are not enough to guarantee an honest transaction. The DGCCRF regularly publishes injunctions and penalties targeting websites with unfair commercial practices, including misleading prices, non-compliant products and dangerous goods. Before making any online purchase, a few practical checks can help reduce the risk of fraud or disputes.

Third-party sellers on marketplaces: the weak link in trustworthiness

On a well-known marketplace, trust often rests on the platform’s own reputation. This is a logical assumption, but a misleading one: marketplaces host third-party sellers whose identities and stock they do not always verify.

DGCCRF actions can directly target the practices of these third-party sellers and the content they offer online. Checking the seller’s identity is just as important as checking the platform. A seller with no verifiable physical address, no SIRET number (for a French business) or no documented sales history poses a real risk.

The most problematic scenario occurs after you place an order: the third-party seller disappears, their store is deactivated, and the platform directs you to lengthy mediation procedures. To protect yourself, it is worth checking whether a website is trustworthy before proceeding to checkout, paying close attention to the seller’s profile rather than just the marketplace interface.

If a third-party seller has disappeared, save the offer page (take a screenshot), your order confirmation and all correspondence. These documents are essential evidence when filing a complaint with the platform or contacting a mediator.

Man checking an online store on his smartphone before making a purchase to verify its security

Legal notices and identification details: what a trustworthy website must display

By law, online stores must publish accessible legal notices. These must include the company’s name or legal name, postal address, telephone number or other contact method, and registration number (RCS or equivalent for a European website).

If this information is missing, that is an immediate red flag. Its presence does not guarantee that a site is trustworthy, but its absence guarantees a potential problem.

Check the seller’s physical address

Copy the postal address listed in the legal notices and look it up on a mapping service. Check whether it corresponds to a commercial premises, warehouse or office that makes sense for the products being sold. An address that points to a vacant lot or residential building should raise concerns.

Terms and conditions of sale and the right to withdraw

The terms and conditions of sale set out delivery, returns and refunds. A website based in the European Union must offer a right of withdrawal. If the terms are missing, written in poor French or copied from another website without being adapted, proceed with caution.

  • Check that the withdrawal period and return conditions are clearly stated, not buried on an inaccessible page.
  • Make sure there is an after-sales service with a working contact method (not just a form that goes unanswered).
  • Search for the company’s name alongside the word “scam” or “reviews” in a search engine to find any reports from other buyers.

Official lists and reporting tools: resources to check

Before placing an order, one simple check is to see whether the website appears on an official list of websites subject to a digital requisition. The DGCCRF publishes such a list. A website’s absence from the list does not prove it is trustworthy, but its presence is an unequivocal warning sign.

Several free tools can also help assess an online store. Google’s Transparency Report (Safe Browsing) indicates whether a URL has been flagged as dangerous. Specialist services analyse the age of the domain name, registration details (Whois) and associated reviews.

Why HTTPS alone does not prove a website is trustworthy

The padlock and HTTPS protocol indicate that the connection between your browser and the server is encrypted. This technical security protects data in transit, but a fraudulent website can easily have an HTTPS certificate. HTTPS protects the connection, not the seller’s good faith.

Computer screen displaying an HTTPS padlock and trust badges to secure an online purchase

Payment security and what to do after a purchase

When paying, choose payment methods that offer some form of recourse: a bank card with a chargeback procedure, or a third-party payment service that acts as a buffer between the seller and your banking details.

  • A website that only accepts bank transfers or prepaid cards severely limits your options if a dispute arises.
  • If a website redirects you to a payment page whose URL does not match your bank or a recognised provider (Stripe, PayPal, Adyen), do not proceed.
  • After purchasing, always keep your order confirmation, invoice and screenshots of the offer as it appeared when you placed the order.

Keeping evidence of the offer and the seller makes it easier to take action later. Decisions published by the DGCCRF show that disputes can involve the advertised price, product compliance or safety—not just non-delivery.

One final point that is often overlooked: consumer reviews are not all reliable. A large number of positive reviews posted within a short period and using similar wording may indicate that fake reviews have been purchased. Always compare reviews across several sources and favour verified-review platforms over reviews displayed directly on the seller’s website.

How to Check Whether an Online Store Is Trustworthy Before You Buy